High Intensity Training Q and A (continued)

Apr 16, 2009 4:44 PM

This post is a continuation of this post (videos included).

The goal of this post is simple-to answer more basic (but not so obvious) Q and A.

To recap from the previous post....

-High Intensity Training is more effective (results) and efficient (time) than any other form of exercise I know of, by leaps and bounds no less.

-HIT is brief, intense, and infrequent (an oversimplification but the essentials).

-HIT requires exercise not to last very long, and not to happen very often (intensity drops off when duration/frequency increase, slowing or reversing progress)

-HIT, properly performed, is so safe it's ridiculous.

-I've personally dropped my body fat % to 8.8, after being stuck at over 11% for half a year. I did this through about 3 months of a once a week HIT session (about a dozen workouts lasting 10-15 minutes a piece), and eliminating nearly all forms of traditional "cardio". I ate exactly the same during this time period.

-Leading up to this I was running up to 2.5 hours at a time, taking group ex classes, and swimming up to 45 minutes straight at a time.

-HIT is effective for both fat loss and building muscle (the two are interrelated and next to inseparable).

-HIT is IMO, the best way to preserve your health now, and decades down the road. Point blank period.

Ok so moving on to new stuff that could use some further explanation.

1. Frequency: from the e-mails I've received- and personal experience with this- I think the drastic reduction in frequency/duration when compared to "cardio"and high volume traditional training- is the biggest obstacle for people to overcome that have been working out "religiously"in the past.

So I'll do a little repeating (frequency first)

An increase in intensity demands a decrease in frequency. You simply can not work out at a high enough intensity to stimulate optimal muscle growth more than once or twice per week. 3 times possibly-if you have a ridiculous recovery ability- but even then it will likely lead to overtraining.

That said-it's not a big deal if you work out twice a week. "Once a week"is arbitrary. Your body has no understanding of a "week", it just needs time to recover/repair/grow muscles once you tear them down.

You may be ready to work out in 3/4/5 days, or maybe 8/9...it depends on the individual. Other factors come into play as well-age primarily-followed by nutrition/sleep etc. But really it comes down to time.

So, if you're in your late teens/early twenties-I'm 20 myself- once every 5 days may work fine for you if you're eating even close to a proper diet. Once a week (every 7 days) is not a law, it's just good advice for a large and diverse audience.

Sounds nice on paper to =).

But being "ready"to work out again isn't the only factor. The one most people don't think about is the base line as Doug Mcguff puts it.

Think about it, what is your goal with working out? Probably a better level of "fitness", bigger muscles, more flexibility maybe... (all interelated actually).

What you don't want is to be tired/sore all the time. Who would?

Well think about it in a hypothetical situation.

Joe- a 22 year old male- performs a high intensity work out. His body takes a full 3 days with good rest and diet to recover.

What's the answer? Get up on day 4-the first day he's physiologically ready- and tear his muscles back down?

When does he ever get to enjoy an enhanced musculature? The answer is never if he's that wrapped up with working out.

But Joe is really motivated!

Well then Joe missed the memo, the answer is not more, it's less. If Joe really cares about his health/body he won't be so obssessed with working out that he's in a constant state of repair.

Personally, I think at 20 my body can handle once every 4 or 5 days- temporarily- if I'm resting and not doing anything else on the off days.

Right now I still play 2 hours of dodgeball every monday and teach 2 HIIT jump rope classes Wednesday and Thursday of each week (Thursday I try to take it easy).

Hence I've stuck with once every 7 days for over 3 months. But who knows, maybe my body can't handle that much exercise and waiting 8 or 9 days maybe actually benefit my progress. We'll have to wait and see.

2. Duration: this is another issue many people-myself included at one point- may have with high intensity training. It usually doesn't last more than 10-15 minutes.

Well it can if you're at a commercial gym that's packed, but ideally you're hopping from machine to machine with no break, which usually results in a 10-15 minute work out.

I guess most people are used to looking at an eliptical machine for 15 minutes and that's their point of reference for a "15 minute workout".

In reality, 15 minutes of a proper HIT session is the equaivalent of an all out sprint with every major muscle group- group by group.

It's "serverly uncomfortable", and does not tickle by any means. By the time you're done, you may be ready to vomit, and you certaintly aren't interested in more exercise (assuming you understand that "more" will probably be counter productive due to a drastic decrease in intensity).

3. One set to failure: this one is a little harder to explain, and is probably better "felt"by doing a proper HIT workout than me trying to explain, but basically one set is all you need to do if it's done right-slowly to avoid momentum build up, and correctly to prevent injury.

The # of reps arent a big deal, what matters is your TUL (time under load) to failure-when you can no longer move the weight. The HIT community varies on the "best"time range to stay in, but from what I've seen most agree that anywhere from 50-90 seconds is going to produce RESULTS.

Some do it slower with a 10 up 10 down cadence and going up to 3 minutes before hitting failure, but from what I've read on Drew Baye's blog, that's excessive and possibly not quite as productive (regarding the TUL, the rep cadence is a different story).

I think one set to failure would have been less of an issue after posting the video if tightening my face/screaming/holding my breath were positive habits for strength training, but, they are not.

People may look "bad ass"in a gym screaming and not keeping their faces relaxed, but when it comes down to it it's a lot harder to NOT do these things than to give in to those instincts that will prevent muscle inroad.

As I said before, HIT hurts. It is rarely fun-I say rarely because there is a sense of enjoyment and satisfaction from doing things right and pushing through an urge to STOP the exercise- and never tickles.

that's all for now folks

-Dream

edit- On the subject of one set to failure, its worth noting that a major point of HIT is to push each muscle to failure (or close to it depending on who you ask). To accomplish this compound exercises are used, some of which overlap. The chest press/overhead press for example, or even better doing some calf raises before a leg press.

The calves are a supporting muscle, and are used in a leg press, but probably wont fail on time with your quads/hamstrings.

With pushing exercises (overhead/chest) its similar. They use the same muscle groups, but in different ways. Point being, doing a similar exercise (as I did during my video demonstration) is a second set of sorts, its just a set that's worthwhile unlike repeating the same movement over again.